Sunday, January 12, 2020
How Does Mary Shelley Explore Suffering in Frankenstein
How does Shelley portray suffering in ââ¬Å"Frakensteinâ⬠? Throughout the novel, suffering of not only an individual but also humanity, remains at the heart of the plot. Many critics today believe that this suffering comes from the troubled and tormented life Shelley had. For example from 1815 to mid 1819, Shelley was to lose the first three of her four children, for which she held herself responsible. Therefore, it could be argued that the monster is the embodiment of Shelleyââ¬â¢s suffering and guilt. Suffering in the novel becomes apparent through the narrator, Frankenstein. For example, from a psychoanalystââ¬â¢s perception ofVictor, his suffering comes from his character. Victor is the very incarnation of the Byronic Hero. He represents a lonely, isolated and self-à ? destructive force vulnerable to his own over-à ? powering emotions of greed and fervid curiosity. This is perfectly depicted in Caspar David Friedrichââ¬â¢s painting (commonly associated with the image of the Byronic hero) ââ¬Å"Wanderer above the sea of fogâ⬠whereby a man overlooks an untouched landscape (Byronââ¬â¢s poem The Corsair; ââ¬Å"lone, wild and strange, he stood alike exempt from all affection and all contemptâ⬠) with the sole desire to explore and gain victory. This passionately intense nd over-à ? powering desire of knowledge is perfectly depicted in Book IV of Miltonââ¬â¢s Paradise Lost ââ¬ËSatanââ¬â¢s address to the sunââ¬â¢ (An epic poem heavily influencing Shelley) whereby Satan must suffer for his ââ¬Å"Pride and worse ambitionâ⬠. It is therefore blatant that Frankensteinââ¬â¢s immense feelings of isolation (Byron; ââ¬Å"That man of loneliness and mysteryâ⬠) and fervid desire become the sole cause of Frankensteinââ¬â¢s loss of humanity and mental self-à ? destruction (the use of the phrase ââ¬Å"infernal machinationsâ⬠implying a man so susceptible to his own greed, curiosity and isolation that his o wn mental torment becomes almost an quivalent to Danteââ¬â¢s ââ¬ËInfernoââ¬â¢). Therefore, Victor becomes the ââ¬Å"Satanâ⬠of this novel. Having had an intense yearning for victory (as his name suggests), he has attempted to assume the position of God, which has only caused mental decline and suffering. Aside from his mental torment, Victorââ¬â¢s physical deterioration mirrors his guilt. Frankenstein has held himself responsible for the deaths of his closest friends and family. For example, in Chapter IV-à ? ââ¬Å"I felt the fiendââ¬â¢s grasp in my neckâ⬠a direct link is made to Coleridgeââ¬â¢s (a close friend of William Godwin-à ? Shelleyââ¬â¢s Father) ââ¬ËRime of the Ancient Marinerââ¬â¢ whereby, fter having shot the albatross (once a symbol of good luck), the course of time has been altered forever; ââ¬Å"With my crossbow I shot the Albatrossâ⬠. Consequently, the ââ¬Å"[shooting] of the albatrossâ⬠in this novel comes not f rom Victorââ¬â¢s creation of the monster but infact his crime of denying the monster of love. For example, Rousseau (a philosopher that inspired Shelley) suggested that a child deprived of a loving family becomes a monster. This act of depriving the monster of maternal love (thus, showing menââ¬â¢s incapability of love) caused the monster to kill those closest to Victor. This sparked immense feelings of guilt n Victor ââ¬Å"I was overcome by gloom and miseryâ⬠linking to Coleridgeââ¬â¢s poem (ââ¬Å"And I had done a hellish thingâ⬠), which inevitably becomes the cause of his physical decline ââ¬Å"The human frame could not longer support the agonizing suffering that I enduredâ⬠. It is therefore, through the ââ¬Å"hellishâ⬠act of denying the monster of love, that ââ¬Å"The Albatross about [Victorââ¬â¢s] neck was hungâ⬠and his supreme guilt lead to his suffering. Victorââ¬â¢s physical deterioration in this novel also confirms the idea of à ¢â¬Å"The Doubleâ⬠. As many critics have suggested, the monster is merely a projection of Frankensteinââ¬â¢s innate corruption. It is hence ossible to assume that Frankensteinââ¬â¢s physical suffering and loss of humanity comes from the monsterââ¬â¢s increased power thus showing how these two individuals are linked. The idea of such a double is backed up by the fact that the monster kills at moonlight and thus, the moon acts as an illuminating object shining into the heart of Victor only to reveal the monster. Such a theme is present in Stevensonââ¬â¢s ââ¬Å"Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hydeâ⬠whereby; the suppressed emotions of Dr, Jekyll are projected at night in the ultra-à ? ego of Mr. Hyde. However, a far greater suffering is observed within the monster. The suffering comes withinThe Daemonââ¬â¢s rejection from his creator Frankenstein. The Daemon has lost any parental influence or more importantly, he has failed to achieve his ââ¬Å"father figureâ⬠. Con stant desire to be appreciated by a father is a theme in this novel. For example, Frankenstein felt safe and secure in the presence of his father (ââ¬Å"Nothing, at this moment, could have given me greater pleasure than the arrival of my fatherâ⬠) and Shelley herself longed for the appreciation and love from her father (especially after, William Godwin cut off relations to Shelley after her marriage to Percy). However, the monster, much like Adam from ParadiseLost, has failed to be appreciated by Victor (who he views as his father). In Paradise Lost, Adam had a constant desire to please God, but due to the temptation of Eve, he was outcast and rejected. This is similar to the monster, as purely to his appearance, the monster has been denied love from his father thus giving rise to an Oedipus complex. This Oedipus complex (also present in Shakespeareââ¬â¢s Macbeth) is shown through the monster as, when Frankenstein rejects the monster, the monster seemingly denounces him as a father and instead views his mother (possibly, nature) as the only love he will ever receive (ââ¬Å"He was soon orne away by the wavesâ⬠-à ? last sentence, Page 191). Therefore, this rejection of love from a paternal influence based on the monsterââ¬â¢s appearance of ââ¬Å"horror and disgustâ⬠(page 39) has lead to a loss of identity within the monster, and thus a mental anguish and suffering (ââ¬Å"who am miserable beyond all living things-à ? page 77). This suffering the monster feels is extended by societyââ¬â¢s further rejection of him based on his appearance. The fact that he is even rejected by the DeLaceys is Shelleyââ¬â¢s view that everyone, however seemingly perfect, has an innate ability to judge based on appearance. This is why the monster s, at first, welcomed into the house of DeLacey. He is blind and therefore does not possess humanityââ¬â¢s evil ability to judge based on appearance-à ? he therefore is the very quintessence of purity an d kindness at the heart of a judgmental society as he does not possess sight. Shelley therefore attempts to suggest that humanityââ¬â¢s most dangerous quality is sight. This allows The Monster to believe he really is ââ¬Å"a daemonâ⬠/ ââ¬Å"wretchâ⬠/ ââ¬Å"foul beingâ⬠and suffers due to it. However, despite the suffering of the individual, this novel seems to address a far greater suffering; the suffering of humanity. Linking once again toMiltonââ¬â¢s Paradise Lost, the ââ¬Ëultimate sinââ¬â¢ of Eve stealing the forbidden fruit leads to Adam and Eve (the first humans and thus, our ancestors) to be outcast to the wilderness. The suffering of humanity therefore comes from the fact that we, as descendants of Adam and Eve must be held responsible for Adam and Eveââ¬â¢s actions and temptation. Therefore, the human existence is based on the belief that we must continually repent for our ancestorââ¬â¢s sins and leads to the theory that the monster is mer ely the embodiment of Godââ¬â¢s vengeance, warning the most corrupt humans who attempt to overcome nature (which is sublime and God-à ? ontrolled) that, God will prevail. This is however a use of irony. Mary Shelley married Percy Shelley 3 years after he was expelled from Oxford for his pamphlet ââ¬Å"The necessity of atheismâ⬠. This therefore exposes Shelleyââ¬â¢s cynicism of religion, whereas it should be based on glorifying existence, it is in fact, based on the suffering of humanity. Further suffering of humanity is observed through the treatment of sexuality in the novel. When Adam and Eve were cast out into the wilderness in Paradise Lost, they had to commit the ââ¬Ëoriginal sinââ¬â¢ of sexual reproduction as a means to produce offspring and ensure the survival f humanity. This act therefore undermines Godââ¬â¢s power as it shows nature and science cannot be controlled by God (who is allegedly ââ¬Ëthe creator of allââ¬â¢). Therefore, within Victori an society a religiously backed suppression of sexuality meant men could not show any signs of sexual desire and that instead they must be kept secret. This leads to the idea that the monster is infact the depiction of Frankensteinââ¬â¢s sexual desire and that, much like the monster, it is locked away in the human body and allowed to ââ¬Ëfesterââ¬â¢ it will only be more ugly and violent (as shown in Elizabethââ¬â¢s death and Frankensteinââ¬â¢s destruction of he female monster which seem to almost mirror an aggressive rape). Moreover, this leads to the development of what is more commonly known as ââ¬Å"The Queer Theoryâ⬠. This entails the idea that Frankenstein has a secretly oppressed homosexual desire which was shunned upon by Victorian society and that the only way to reveal this homo-à ? erotic desire was to create the ââ¬Å"daemonâ⬠as a male Adonis ââ¬Å"I selected his features a beautifulâ⬠in order to fulfil his suppressed sexuality. Theref ore, humanity suffers as their sexuality is oppressed by society and religion meaning that when it is revealed only more suffering is unleashed.Shelley in this novel also speaks from a seemingly feminist perspective. This may have been inspired by her mother, Mary Wollstonecraftââ¬â¢s book ââ¬Å"A Vindication of the rights of womanâ⬠which placed stress on female independence and the importance of female education (women who succumb to sensuality will be ââ¬Å"blown about by every momentary gust of feelingâ⬠); which links to the passive and generally ââ¬Ëpatheticââ¬â¢ description of women in this novel. Theyââ¬â¢re suffering comes from the fact that Eve, the first woman committed the original sin thus damning society into a world far less sublime than the Garden of Eden. Therefore, Shelley esires show how women are forced into submission and general passiveness as a result of being the gender that committed the original sin. Their passiveness, perfectly depic ted in Elizabeth and Justine, links well to Coventry Patmoreââ¬â¢s poem, The Angel in the house. This poem states the power men possess over women and that, to remain included in society, women must remain tacit and pretty so to fulfil the expectations of society. This links to the monster; the monster fails to fulfil societyââ¬â¢s expectations of appearance and therefore is outcast. However, this juxtaposes with women as they fulfil societyââ¬â¢s expectations and
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.